Quinn Weber
9-11-09
Period 1
“On Native Soil”
BLAME EVERYONE!

The story of 9/11 and the aftermath has been well documented, “On Native Soil” tries to take a fresh look at the tragedy by taking a look at the family members of those lost in the September 11th attacks whom were responsible for the formation of the 9/11 commission. After a brief overview of the history of the USA and Al Queda, the film dives into that horrific day, attempting to step by step breaking down the many steps of incompetence which were committed. At the same time the documentary shows the testimony of those it pens responsible and the reactions of the family members and 9/11 commission.
Linda Ellman’s “On Native Soil” features many eye-witness interviews and inspirational and gut-wrenching stories of survivors. From the story of Brian and Stanley’s escape from tower 2 to David Lim’s rescue mission all the stories are touching. The film itself is narrated by powerful actors: Kevin Costner and Hillary Swank.
“On Native Soil” manages to avoid the groove which many of it fellow documentaries fall into- the abyss of boredom. The film features lots of interesting testimony, well-lit interviews, recorded conversations, and explosions to keep the viewer interested. The interweaving stories are very interesting and it seems like almost every type of victim is represented; from the family of those on board, those in the towers, to those in the pentagon. Certainly “On Native Soil” Did its homework and had an excellent team of editors and producers.
The downfalls of documenting such a devastating event will always be that the outcome will be weighty. “On Native Soil” not only presents the deceased, it attacks our entire government and more as incompetent. From the FAA and Condoleezza Rice to Airline Security and the New York rescue teams; everyone is under attack. The film gives no merit to what was attempted to do, the efforts of the firemen or police in New York, and also no recognition to the efforts at the pentagon. The only time the movie is not completely depressing is when it is depicting the struggle on board flight 93 which crash landed in Shanksville.
“On Native Soil” is a well done, educational documentary, which covers a historic even that should never be forgotten, but should we remember this day only for how our nation failed? By pointing fingers at those who the family members blame, the documentary hopes to reform the government. This film seems to be more of a political tool for gathering anti-government sentiments than a documentary depicting the story of those lost. After watching “On Native Soil, the viewer has almost the same symptoms after watching a PETA video.
The attacks on September 11th are well filmed, there are many other documentaries on the market today which present a much more balanced argument against the nation, while giving deeper background into the terrorist attacks and presenting information in a non-opinionated way. Documentaries are supposed to inform the viewer, not influence them. "On Native Soil" should be watched only after many alternatives have been exhausted and more oppinions are still craved. Im going to stay with the history channel specials.